3.18.2009

Just a sec. I'm on my soap box.


Yep. Just one of those things. I have to go there. A couple friends have posted about one of my FAVORITE subjects, and I have to say SOMETHING. Realized that I should PROBABLY do it on my blog once I noticed I had just ABOUT written a book when I commented on KAREN'S blog... and I commented THREE times on COFFEE'S.
My friend Karen homeschools her children. Coffee is thinking about homeschooling her children. SO. I have a lot of things I need to say, and I'm not going to be able to get it all out here in the orderly way that I would like to, so please bear with me. If you read Karen and Coffee's posts, this post might make more sense.

I don't really know WHERE to start. I think that the choice TO homeschool or not to homeschool is VERY personal. While I'm going to be emphasizing the benefits of homeschool here, I also need to share that I think public school DOES have a place. There are kids who thrive there. My kids are in public school right now. As a child, I was home schooled for 11 of my k-12 years, and graduated as a homeschooler. THIS post is about the reasons that homeschool is ALSO a great place for kids to be. That's what I'll be focusing on. What you take from this, and the decisions you make for YOUR family might not be the same that someone else will take from it, and that's alright.
What IS homeschool:
Simply put, homeschooling means that parents are in charge of what and how their kids learn, and they do it in their home. One reason parents homeschool is religious belief. If you are a christian, and you do not believe that evolution is scientific fact, it's pretty disheartening to see that public schools teach evolution AS fact. It's saddening that even though there are many credible scientists who show just as much evidence that creation is fact, creation is usually not even MENTIONED in public schools as theory, let alone plausible truth. There are other religious differences that clash with home vs public school. Religious reasons aren't the ONLY reasons to homeschool, and many parents who choose to kept their children at home aren't religious at all. They have other reasons to homeschool. Some as simple as the fact that public schools aren't a good fit for their child.
Structure, Socialization and Routine:
Staying at home to go to school doesn't mean everyone sleeps until noon. It doesn't mean that no one EVER has to keep an appointment ever again. It doesn't mean that we never have to answer to anyone for anything ever again. To say that, seems so absurd to me. By the very nature of being a human being in a SOCIETY, you have obligations and interactions that can be learned from no matter what your age or where you go to school. Even if you are taking an Unschooling approach to your child's education, there ARE routines in your day. They are just not the SAME. I don't understand where along the line it made sense to live EXACTLY the same routine, and EXACTLY the same days and read EXACTLY the same books in order to be able to function. In my opinion, it's just silly, and impractical. As to the "routine" that public school offers, and how our kids should have them in order to be prepared for LIFE, I'd like you to visit THIS ARTICLE. There are little to no instances in adulthood that parallel the public school environment. Lisa Russell says what I wish EVERYONE would take a moment to think about. Really. And as far as protecting kids from parts of life at a young age... Really? You think that kids are REALLY ready to face the harsh world that we adults have come to know and love? REALLY?!? Because I think it's much wiser to prepare them. There is nothing wrong with protecting your kids. There is nothing wrong with staying safe. In the REAL public school system, there is much more than daily routine and deadlines being thrown at our kids. Why is it necessary for them to face these things as children? To me, it's the equivalent of saying something like this. There is a known drug dealer on your street. In order to keep from sheltering your kids, you tell them they HAVE to go over and play there, so they can face the REAL world. You don't want to shelter them, so they MUST go into that house and see the drugs, and try to tell the drug pusher that they don't WANT to do them... they just have to be exposed to them so they can live a life that's not sheltered. The idea is just absurd. Kelli Crowe has thoughts similar to this HERE. Homeschooling your kids won't make them introverts. Just like public school won't make them extroverts. We are who we are, and homeschooling is just one way to learn. It's one way to gain experiences. There will be ups. There will be downs. There will be times when your child feels like they don't have any friends no matter WHERE they go to school. That's because those experiences are part of LIFE. They aren't specific to public vs. homeschool.
What kids are learning in Public School vs. HomeSchool:
Public School: If you REALLY think, that kids are learning to be kind and respectful, that they in turn are being treated fairly and being given solid one on one instruction, you haven't had a kid in public school for a LONG time. The truth is, that most teachers don't have the time or resources to give good one on one instruction anymore. Classrooms are growing every year, and staff is shrinking. The truth is, if your child doesn't "get" the math lesson that day, there won't be many chances for them TO get it. The class will move on, and your child will sink or swim. The truth is, that there are kids in class will most likely NEVER respect others. Teachers aren't teaching "respect". The teachers CAN'T do their job, because PARENTS aren't doing their job. The domino effect on a child is very powerful. The fact is, that many kids who are labeled hard to teach, trouble makers, and disruptive in class aren't bad kids at all. They just don't fit into a cookie cutter mold that "they" decided all kids should fit in. Those kids KNOW that their teacher finds them difficult. They KNOW that they aren't liked. Teachers don't have to come out and say it. The fact is, that this haven of a public school so many people speak so highly of doesn't exist.
Homeschool: If a child isn't flourishing in the public school, the advantage to homeschool is that a person who is emotionally invested in their well being is there to help them make the BEST of the way they learn. That adult is there to help them when they flounder, and be there with them for those light bulb moments. That person has TIME to give one on one instruction, even IF they are teaching more than one child at a time, because their "classroom" only has a handful of kids compared to a public school's 25-30 kids to every teacher. Homeschooling allows a child to take the time they need to REALLY learn a math lesson, rather than learn enough to pass a test and forget it later. The advantages to homeschool are many. YOU decide how your child will learn. Some children don't do well with structure. They enjoy seizing opportunity in baking cookies to learn about measurement, and they spend hours reading books and figuring out how to create a bird blind to study birds. They relish in polling friends and family and creating a graph about what flavor pie is the Thanksgiving favorite. They don't even realize they are learning. LIFE is their lesson. The fact is, that there is a place for EVERYONE in this world. The fact is, that even if you aren't taught in the same "structure" of a scheduled school day, you can still understand responsibility. You can still meet deadlines. (finishing building a fort before dark, taking cookies out of the oven before they burn, helping to keep the laundry clean in order to HAVE clean clothes, coming along with mom, who is keeping the vet appointment to keep the dog healthy.) These things we learn about everyday life AREN'T taught in a public school. They are taught through LIVING.
Wet Blanket:
I get tired of people making blanket statements about homeschool AND public school. The ones that make it clear to me that they haven't EVER seriously thought about the words before they let them out of their mouth. They are blanket statements that are wet, and smothering. They snuff out any serious and REAL conversation that could be had about the subject. These statements... I could never teach my kids. I don't have the patience. I'm not organized enough. If you want to teach, you should become a school teacher. Children NEED to be in school to socialize. They're BULL SHIT. If homeschool is right for you, you make homeschool fit YOU. That's the beauty!! There are many MANY styles to learning. You choose the one that fits YOUR family. If making your home into a mini school is what your child needs, go for it. Chances are, if that's the kind of child you have, they got a lot of their tendencies from you, and that style will mesh with your household better than you think. If you prefer a child led schooling day, then take it!! Let your child's interests and curiosity lead you to the next field trip, or lesson. If you need books and assignments, there are resources out there for you. AND. Just because you're considering teaching your kids, doesn't mean you WANT to teach other people's kids. It's kind of like saying, "You want to have kids? You should just do DAYCARE." It's not the same thing. One of the downfalls to public school is that it ISN'T flexible.You either do well there, or you don't. If you don't, the options aren't very great for you to find a way to succeed there.
My Experiences:
When I was a child, I had THE BEST education. The best one for ME. I was interested in horses. We went to the library, and read just about every book I could find on them. My dad talked to a co worker who owned horses, and even though we never owned a horse, I can RIDE. :P I was interested in being a vet. My mom talked to a vet at our church, and I got to sit in on several spays and neuter procedures, count blood cells and parasites on a microscope, help a calf be born, and watch the vet inspect cattle at auction. I learned to train dogs and how to "speak" dog through 4-H and more books. I had my own dark room as a kid. A KID. I was 12 stinking years old, and I had my own dark room. One summer, we set up an old travel trailer near a pond on my grandma's property, because we wanted to study the wildlife. We used to pack lunch, and go visit the pond, and draw pictures of the fish we saw. One summer, I took an impromptu trip with a church high school choir and toured with them into California for a couple weeks. All things that I probably wouldn't have had time to do, if I had been in public school. My little sister didn't learn like me. Her homeschool experience was totally different than mine, and yet we spent our days together. My mom made that happen. SHE made sure that both our needs were met. She did all this back when there was question about whether homeschooling would officially be legal. Back when curriculum companies didn't usually SELL to homeschool families, and she managed to do it. It was moms and dads like her that paved the way for what homeschool has become today.
I took Ian (my 14 year old at the time) Out of school for his 8th grade year. The move here to our town wasn't easy for him. The boys at school were harassing him, to the point that we could have called the police dept. and pressed charges of sexual harassment. To the point that other kids he considered his FRIENDS stopped talking to him because they couldn't handle the things that Ian was dealing with from those other kids, but Ian couldn't get away from himself. He was stuck. It was beating down his spirit, and I could see it. I could see my happy, kind, and easy going son losing himself a little more each day. He was a good student, and hard worker, and still, was coming home with homework that took him so many hours he was falling behind. It was consuming him, and it was frivolous. The work that was being sent home was filler. As if spending 8 hours a day in school wasn't enough time to learn what he needed to learn. As if our FAMILY didn't need to spend time together AFTER school. So I took him out. We relaxed the whole year. I didn't worry about what he did or didn't get done. I just let him decompress, and repair his spirit. He went back to school this year, and is doing GREAT. But what he NEEDED was to come HOME for that year. To sit back, and take a BREATH. When he went back to school, there wasn't one hiccup. The boys that gave him such grief had moved on. He's happy and whole. I know I did the right thing for HIM.
What Homeschooling has become today:
Still with me? If you're still here, THANKS!! If you're thinking about homeschool, and would like more information, there are endless possibilities just here on the net!! I suggest the following links.
What about College?
It is increasingly easy for homeschool students to gain entrance into presidious colleges. HERE is a good link with information about life after homeschool in relation to college.
Homeschool STYLES:
Resources:
Homeschool Legal Defense (great place to research your state's laws)
About Homeschooling
Homeschool.com
The Homeschool Mom
Books:
Growning without Schooling
The Teenage Liberation Handbook
Online schools with free public schooling from your home:
k12
Connections Academy

The choices and options are endless. No matter WHAT your budget. No matter HOW well you think you can teach. Whether you want a Christian approach or a Secular one. There is a choice out there for YOU. Don't let someone ELSE make your decision for you. It's YOUR choice. It's as personal as the day you decided to HAVE kids. It's as personal as the choice of church you do or do not attend. It's not up to someone else. What another person thinks about your choice shouldn't matter. They aren't YOU, and they don't live in your convictions and your day to day. You can always change your mind. There are no laws saying that once you decide one thing, you can't decide to take a new or different path. It's called a JOURNEY, and if you don't take the scenic route once in a while, you're missing out on a LOT.

13 Peeps Cheeped:

  1. Read the whole thing. LOVED it. Thanks for the great info! I wish certain people (read: husbands) could be a little more open-minded.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Best post on homeschooling EVER.

    I struggled with "structure" when I first started homeschooling my daughter (she's 17 and never has gone to public/private school).

    I thought I totally screwed-up ... thought I was ruining her education. Then we started "unschooling." Duh! The whole reason why I wanted to homeschool was because I didn't want my daughter learning ONE WAY!

    Marissa is incredibly smart in so many subjects, 'cos she had/has time to really consume what she is interested in (and it's a lot!). She is not "good" in "school math" -- but when it comes to figuring out money/math, she uses COMMON SENSE, not a SET FORMULA to come up with the right answer -- and has helped me a ton of times!

    And the whole "socialization" thing is so ridiculous! Know how many interesting people you get to meet + interact with + learn from when you're not in a classroom for 7 hours a day, five days a week!?
    Marissa knows so many people - of all walks-of-life who ADORE her! Why? 'Cos she has SOCIAL SKILLS and knows how to HOLD A CONVERSATION! She never had to be scared about talking out of place or raising her hand to speak!

    OK, going to stop now, 'cos I can go on and on.

    Thanks for making my day! Even after all these years, this blog post helped lift more guilt off my shoulders!

    ReplyDelete
  3. AMEN, AMEN, AMEN! I'm with you all the way. I recently took one of my kids out of school for some decompression time. Best thing I ever did for her. After 2 plus years of psychiatric visits and more drugs than I can mention - I gave up on the "treatment", and found out the real direction she needed to go. It is NOT "organized schooling". She is finally NOT trying to hurt herself, actually WANTS to live, and is looking forward to getting her GED. Great article!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is an absolutely fabulous rant and I'm glad you ranted it. I like the word rant so I am paying you a compliment. In any case, I have learned a lot and I have appreciated the links you have provided. I disagree with you on one fundamental thing, but this is your blog and it's none of my business. All I'm saying is, I really like it that you used your blog to express with eloquence and rationality something that I know you've been wanting to express for some time. So, thanks. Thanks for the EDUCATION, too. hahaHAHAHAH!! See? the education?

    okay.

    ReplyDelete
  5. LOVE, LOVE, LOVED the rant. Feel free to rant on my blog any time! And thank yew for yer support.

    ReplyDelete
  6. A very interesting read. Sounds like your homeschool experience was fantastic. I, along with my sister and two brothers, did homeschool for most of my schooling years. I do appreciate many aspects of having done homeschool but there are things I missed. I did homeschool via the Accelerated Christian Education which was basically correspondance. My parents supervised and helped if we needed it but we were mostly left to work on our books. Reading and writing answers. Writing has always been enjoyable but I miss not having had the chance to do things like photography and more hands on art and woodwork etc. But we were also able to go on family holidays as we decided and I could work mostly at my own pace. My sister is now a nurse and my brothers didn't complete y12 but both have trades (coz thier more hands on) and my older bro is now studying to be a chaplain in the army. So it certainly doesn't hinder one's growth and learning.

    ReplyDelete
  7. LeeAnne @ coastrain3/18/09 6:01 PM

    with my two in Connections Academy...i agree! Lil J is 1000% better than here in a Bricks&Mortar school and Big J has found a love of learning....but fyi the teachers union, the administrators union and the school board assn want to close all oregon virtual schools to send our $ back to the home school districts.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Whoa .. I read every word you wrote.. gave me many things to think about!!! I have four children (one who is in special education) who just struggle in the PS environment .. I have gotten to the point that I am ready to walk away and lose whatever I have to to stay home with them, thinking if I could stay home I could be more present in the school and that might make a differance .. but Im not so sure that it would, I have become so annoyed with the schools anti bullying policy(because really .. like you said, it starts at HOME .. teachers cant teach that, the endless pointless homework ... I could go on and on! I admit, I was one of those that said I could never homeschool my kids, my patience are limited, I couldnt teach them etc .. but ya know, Im Wrong! I am off to check out the links and I think I will re-read your post .. Thanks Rachel, I needed this!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. My sister homeschooled her kids until recently and it had nothing to do with religious reasons. Her favorite book on the subject:
    The Call To Brilliance by Resa Brown

    And of course, my sister's kids are the most brilliant kids EVER ;)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hey Rachel. I really enjoyed this. I don't have any kids yet, but you make some REALLY good points. I've never really considered home school because I wasn't home schooled, but it's always nice to know I have options. My mom did home school my younger brother because he has disabilities, and he's doing really well. I'm there with ya sister!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Rachel I just read your "article" :)I loved it! I couldn't have written/said it any better...I was homeschooled too and I am homeschooling all my girls 11,8,24month! Boy we are kindred spirits!

    ReplyDelete
  12. My sixth grade daughter just revealed to me that LAST year her gym teacher had thrown an ice bag at her when she wasn't sitting in the proper formation for an activity. Then her friend told me that the same teacher had kicked her in the butt when she was walking when she was supposed to be running. After I reported this to the administration, my daughter said that this same teacher came up behind her and her friend when they were walking (instead of running) and he screamed "RUN" at the top of his lungs. My daughter said it scared her to death. She is in a junior high this year and I am keeping a diligent eye out. I just started a blog today. My first blog isn't real interesting but the rest will be about the school district and they lack of information our local paper provides us when things go wrong in the schools here. I got pretty tired of finding things out from the local gossip chain instead of the newspaper, especially when it involved the people teaching our children. So I started my own blog, but I just did a search to see if it came up on google and it didn't so I'm not sure how helpful it will be.
    I enjoyed your article and links very much.

    ReplyDelete
  13. As a student in a public school, I admit I bristled a bit when I started to read your (somewhat long, and you're right there is a LOT of homework :P) entry. But this blog reminded me of a discussion there was in English class the other day, regarding whether a rigorous, brutally structured school system was really necessary for education. I think that for...a certain number of kids, public school works. It does provide a decent base education for a lot of kids. Of course it's not perfect, and it doesn't work for everyone, but it helps to (this will sound crude) "educate the masses".

    ReplyDelete

Hey, you! I appreciate that you are taking the time to join the conversation!! If you ask a question, please be sure to subscribe to the follow up comments so that you'll get my reply! (you can unsubscribe once you get it.)

This Site is Protected by Mouse Chaser